If you owe the IRS and also have several years of unfiled tax returns, it is natural to wonder whether you can negotiate the existing debt first and deal with the missing returns later. The short answer is that in most cases you cannot. The IRS generally requires taxpayers to be in filing compliance before it will consider an Offer in Compromise or most longer-term installment agreements, and an offer submitted while returns are missing may be returned without being evaluated.
That does not mean you must pay every past due balance in full before seeking help. Filing compliance and payment are two different issues. A taxpayer may be unable to pay thousands of dollars in back taxes but can still take important steps toward resolving the problem by first determining which returns are missing, filing the required returns, and establishing an accurate total balance.
Once the IRS has the required returns and the actual liability is known, it becomes possible to evaluate options such as an Offer in Compromise, an installment agreement, Currently Not Collectible status, or other forms of IRS tax relief depending on the circumstances. The sections below explain what the IRS actually requires, why it requires it, and what the order of operations looks like in practice.
Filing Compliance Usually Comes Before Tax Settlement
The IRS generally requires taxpayers to file all legally required tax returns before it will consider an Offer in Compromise. An Offer in Compromise is an agreement that may allow a qualifying taxpayer to settle tax debt for less than the full amount owed, but simply owing more than you can afford does not automatically make you eligible. The IRS evaluates factors such as income, necessary living expenses, assets, equity, and overall ability to pay, and it expects taxpayers to be current with required filings before an offer can move forward.
This requirement makes practical sense from the IRS’s perspective. The government cannot accurately evaluate a proposed settlement if additional tax liabilities may still be hiding in unfiled years. Imagine someone who owes $35,000 for two filed tax years but has not filed returns for the following three years. If those missing returns produce another $20,000 in tax debt, evaluating a settlement based only on the original $35,000 would not provide an accurate picture of the taxpayer’s total liability. This example is for illustration only, and every taxpayer’s situation is different, but the point holds across cases: the missing years generally need to be addressed before a meaningful settlement analysis can take place.
What the IRS Means by Filing Compliance
Filing compliance for settlement purposes involves more than the missing income tax returns. Based on IRS guidelines, a taxpayer submitting an Offer in Compromise is generally expected to have filed all required tax returns, to have made any required estimated tax payments for the current year if self-employed, and to be current on federal tax deposits if the taxpayer operates a business with employees. A taxpayer in an open bankruptcy proceeding is also generally not eligible to submit an offer.
A common question is whether every missed return from decades past must be filed. Not necessarily. IRS policy generally focuses on the most recent six years of required returns when determining whether a taxpayer is in filing compliance, although the IRS can require earlier years in certain situations, and any year for which the IRS has already assessed tax typically needs to be addressed regardless. Determining exactly which years are required should be one of the first steps in the process, since filing more years than necessary can create additional balances while filing too few leaves the compliance gate closed.
For taxpayers who are not sure where they stand, IRS wage and income transcripts can show which years the IRS has income records for and whether a substitute return has already been prepared for a missing year. That information is usually the starting point for building an accurate picture of what is owed.
Submitting an Offer Before You Are Compliant Usually Backfires
Some taxpayers consider submitting an Offer in Compromise anyway, reasoning that the IRS might evaluate the offer and overlook the missing returns. That approach rarely works. When the IRS determines that required returns have not been filed, it may return the offer rather than reject it on the merits, which means the offer is not evaluated at all. Depending on the circumstances, the application fee and any initial payment submitted with the offer may be applied to the outstanding tax balance rather than refunded, so the attempt can cost money without producing a decision.
A returned offer also costs time. While the offer is pending, the IRS generally suspends active collection, but once it is returned, collection can resume, and the taxpayer is back where they started with the compliance issue still unresolved. Filing the required returns first and then submitting the offer is almost always the more efficient sequence.
You Do Not Have to Pay the Missing Returns in Full Before Seeking Resolution
This distinction is especially important for taxpayers who have delayed filing because they know they cannot afford the resulting balances. Filing a required return does not mean the entire tax must immediately be paid in full. Once the required returns are addressed and the total liability becomes clear, taxpayers who cannot pay the balance may be able to explore IRS resolution alternatives, including paying over time through an installment agreement, seeking an Offer in Compromise, or requesting Currently Not Collectible status because of financial hardship.
Two people with identical IRS balances may qualify for completely different solutions because their incomes, expenses, assets, and future ability to pay are different. For this reason, the objective should not simply be to file the missing returns and hope for the best. The filing process should be connected to a broader plan for resolving whatever tax debt remains afterward.
An Offer in Compromise Requires More Than Filing Old Returns
Getting into filing compliance is important, but it does not guarantee that the IRS will accept an Offer in Compromise. The IRS generally evaluates what it calls the taxpayer’s reasonable collection potential. In practical terms, this means examining how much the government believes it can reasonably collect based on income, necessary expenses, available assets, and equity.
Someone with limited income, minimal assets, and a large tax balance may present a very different case from a taxpayer who owns substantial real estate or has enough monthly disposable income to pay the debt over time. If the IRS determines that the taxpayer can reasonably pay through an installment agreement or available asset equity, an offer for substantially less may not be accepted.
This is why reviewing eligibility before submitting an offer is so important. A properly developed tax resolution strategy should evaluate whether settlement is realistic rather than assuming it is automatically the best solution. Penalty abatement may also be worth evaluating alongside or instead of an offer, since reducing the penalty portion of a balance can sometimes change which resolution option makes the most sense.
A Tax Resolution Strategy Should Address the Entire Problem
Resolving several years of tax problems usually requires more than dealing with one notice or one tax year. The first step is determining which returns are required and gathering enough information to address them accurately. From there, the resulting balances can be reviewed together, and only then does it make sense to evaluate affordability, collection exposure, and the available tax resolution options.
If the IRS has already begun sending collection notices on assessed years, those notices should not be set aside while missing returns are being prepared. A taxpayer may simultaneously be dealing with an existing collection case and additional years that still need to be brought into compliance, and the deadlines in those notices continue to run. The objective should be a complete solution that addresses both the missing returns and the debt they may create.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I submit an Offer in Compromise before filing my missing tax returns?
Generally, no. The IRS requires taxpayers to file all legally required tax returns before an Offer in Compromise can be considered, and an offer submitted while returns are missing may be returned without evaluation. Filing compliance is therefore usually one of the first issues that must be addressed.
Do I have to file every tax return I have ever missed?
Not necessarily. IRS policy generally focuses on the most recent six years of required returns, although the IRS can require additional years in certain situations, and any year the IRS has already assessed typically needs to be addressed. Determining which returns are required should be part of the initial review.
What happens if my past due returns create more tax debt?
The additional balances generally become part of the taxpayer’s overall IRS liability. Once the required returns are filed and the total debt is established, the taxpayer can evaluate which resolution options may be available for the combined balance.
Can I get an IRS payment plan if I have unfiled returns?
Filing compliance generally matters when establishing an IRS payment arrangement, particularly for longer term installment agreements. Addressing required missing returns can therefore be an important step before finalizing a payment solution.
Will filing old tax returns automatically trigger IRS collection action?
Filing a past due return does not automatically mean immediate enforcement action will occur. However, if the return creates an unpaid balance, that amount may become subject to the IRS collection process over time. Addressing the filing and payment issues together can help taxpayers prepare for what comes next.
Resolve Unfiled Returns and Back Taxes With a Complete Strategy
Having both unfiled tax returns and back taxes can make an IRS problem feel much more complicated than it needs to be. The important thing is to address the issues in the right order. Getting required returns filed establishes the true amount owed, and once that picture is clear, taxpayers can begin evaluating whether an installment agreement, Offer in Compromise, Currently Not Collectible status, penalty relief, or another tax resolution strategy may be appropriate.
If IRS notices have already started arriving, do not set them aside while the returns are being prepared. The deadlines in those notices can affect the rights and options available to you, and experienced guidance before a major filing or settlement decision generally preserves more of them.
At Anderson Bradshaw Tax Consulting, we help individuals and business owners address multiple years of unfiled tax returns while developing practical strategies for resolving the back taxes that may follow. Our team includes enrolled agents and tax attorneys on staff who serve in a consulting capacity, though Anderson Bradshaw is not a law firm and does not provide legal representation. Our tax professionals can help determine which years need to be addressed, evaluate the IRS balance, review available tax relief options, and guide you through the process with clarity and professionalism.
If you have been avoiding old tax returns because you are worried about what you may owe, continuing to wait usually does not make the uncertainty easier. Schedule a confidential consultation with Anderson Bradshaw Tax Consulting today to understand where you stand and explore a realistic path toward resolving your unfiled returns and IRS tax debt.
Call us at 877.550.3911 or visit www.AndersonBradshawTax.com to learn more.